Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Gaiman: Madman or really smart guy?

I liked it. Classics are classics because they inspire thought and invite interpretation. And while there have been egregious "remakes" and interpretations on past stories (I'm looking at you, Hollywood! Stop remaking movies already!), Gaiman's offering is smart, witty, and an interesting view on Shakespeare's classic.

And yes, I would say that it helps cut through the clutter that the archaic writing sets before the casual reader (and helps with understanding the story better).

The liberties, if anything, lie in the way the play within the story is repeatedly truncated (for the sake of space and time), which is unavoidable. Gaiman does, however, add layers to the characters of the story not readily apparent in the original tale. Puck seems more malevolent in this version (though it might just be the look of him) but he is ever the mischief maker. Titania and Oberon seem much more noble and less petty than the original counterparts and it's all packaged oh so ever neatly.

So yeah, maybe people don't like it because it is not traditional and impugns on some imagined sacred taboo, but that's the whole problem: it's imagined. Literature should not be taken as some untouchable sacred cow but as a work of creativity. And works of creativity should inspire more creativity.

Monday, November 17, 2008

Breaking the fourth wall: Puck's speech

Everybody loves Puck's speech because it's just so gosh darn cool. It appears in great movies like "Dead Poet's Society" because it's so gosh darn cool (which is the primary reason it sticks in my mind like a wet booger).

Anyway, the reason why it is so gosh darned cool is because Puck does something that is quite rare (at least during Shakespeare's period): he breaks the fourth wall. That is instead of being contained within the story of the play he includes the audience by directly speaking to them recognizing the otherwise invisible watchers.

He literally says "well, if you didn't like what you saw tonight, pretend it was a dream!" (Act 5, scene 2...though Puck says it much more eloquently).

It reveals Puck to be a playful lout, the speech that is, but who is nevertheless earnest in his playful ways. He asks to be forgiven for any transgressions done, and that he'd make amends if he has offended, mending any broken friendships.

It is a very tongue in cheek moment.

The language is effective here because it is direct (though some may argue that point). Puck states his intent in the first two lines. The rest of the speech is just following up those thoughts.

The ultimate love triangle thing!

It's been a while since I read the play, so excuse me if I come off a bit muddleheaded.

Oberon loves Titania but, let's face it, he's a bit of a dick. He makes her fall in love with someone else (some vile thing, which turns out to be Bottom), and in some places that would be grounds for divorce.

Or at least a spot on the Maury show (headline: you made me fall in love with an ass so I want a divorce!).

But, as in all of Shakespeare's comedies, everything is resolved in the end and everybody makes up and/or gets married.

Hooray!

Monday, November 3, 2008

Thesis idea maybe?

My basic idea is about how war and conflict causes society to constrict on itself and become insular, forcefully demonizing anything that is foreign to that particular society's core value system. It happened in world war 2 when the american government forced citizens of japanese descent into labour camps, and the post 9-11 environment where arabs were ostracized by the general public, and (most importantly) the systematic banning of all things western by the Iranian government in Sartrapi's Persepolis.

Ugh...sounds heavy. Help!

Oh, and I totally want to do a multi-genre paper. I doubt anybody wants to do a traditional piece.


Addendum: going through everybody's posts...it seems like i was wrong...